Annuities are one of the most misunderstood retirement tools out there. Some people swear by them, and others have been burned by one in the past. The truth is that annuities are not good or bad on their own. They are tools, and like any tool they work great in the right situation and poorly in the wrong one.
I am Bradley Stone, an independent agent representing more than 70 top rated carriers, and I help Central Florida retirees figure out which category they fall into before they sign anything. Because I am independent, I have no incentive to push you into an annuity that does not fit. The first conversation is just a conversation, and I will tell you honestly whether an annuity belongs in your plan at all.
See how much monthly income you would need to cover beyond Social Security and any pension.
This is the steady monthly income a source like a guaranteed annuity could help provide, so the rest of your savings can stay invested. I can show you honestly whether an annuity is the right fit for this gap.
This is an educational estimate, not a quote or a guarantee. Your actual needs, costs, and eligibility depend on your situation and the carrier. Let me run your real numbers with no pressure.
An annuity is a contract with an insurance company. You give the company a lump sum, or a series of payments, and in exchange the company gives you either guaranteed growth, guaranteed income for life, or both. That is the entire idea, stripped of the jargon.
The right annuity can turn a portion of your retirement savings into a paycheck that never runs out, no matter how long you live or what the market does. It can protect a piece of your savings from market losses, or it can grow your money on a tax deferred basis. For many Central Florida retirees, the appeal is simple. They want at least one source of income they can count on without watching the headlines.
Fixed annuities earn a guaranteed interest rate, similar to a certificate of deposit but usually with a higher rate and a longer surrender period. They are a good fit for conservative savers and anyone who wants predictability above all else.
Indexed annuities tie your earnings to the performance of a market index such as the S&P 500, with a floor so you cannot lose principal in a down year, and a cap that limits your gains in a strong year. They suit people who want some market participation without market downside. Variable annuities invest your money directly in market sub accounts and carry the highest upside, the highest downside, and the highest fees. They are rarely the right product, but they are worth understanding so you can recognize when one is being oversold to you.
Beyond the common three, a few other structures solve specific problems.
An immediate annuity turns a lump sum into income that starts right away. It fits someone who needs the largest possible guaranteed paycheck now, either for a set number of years or for life.
A hybrid annuity with long term care pairs retirement value with a long term care benefit. It is a strong option for people who cannot pass the underwriting for a traditional long term care policy, or who would rather solve both needs with one product.
A deferred premium annuity lets you start now with an initial deposit and keep contributing over time, growing on a tax deferred basis until you are ready to turn on income. It is a simple way to build a future paycheck while you are still working.
I start with what you actually need, whether that is guaranteed income, principal protection, tax deferred growth, or beneficiary planning, and I work backward from there. Only after we are clear on the goal do we look at products.
Then I examine carrier financial strength ratings from agencies such as AM Best and Standard and Poor's, surrender schedules, the layers of expenses inside the contract, and any moving parts that affect how the contract behaves over time. Only after all of that do we narrow to a specific product. Most clients end up with one to three annuities total, never a dozen, and never as their entire retirement plan. An annuity should be one well chosen piece of a larger picture.
Florida has a state guaranty association that backs annuity contracts up to set limits if the insurance company itself fails, which adds a layer of protection on top of the carrier's own financial strength. This is one reason carrier selection matters so much, and it is something we evaluate together before you commit.
Florida also offers favorable creditor protection on annuity assets, which can matter for retirees who are concerned about lawsuits or who are thinking carefully about estate planning. These state level details are easy to overlook, but they can be meaningful advantages for Florida residents, and they are part of the full picture I walk you through.

How to turn a lifetime of savings into a reliable paycheck, from Bradley Stone at Stone Financial Partners
Each annuity type solves a different problem, and the clearest way to choose is to match the type to the job you need done.
A multi year guaranteed annuity, often called a MYGA, locks in a set interest rate for a chosen term of several years, much like a certificate of deposit but usually at a higher rate and with the growth tax deferred rather than taxed each year. It is best for a conservative saver who wants a known return over a known period and does not need the money in the meantime. It is not the right fit if you need full access to the funds before the term ends.
A single premium immediate annuity, or SPIA, turns a lump sum into a paycheck that begins almost right away. It is best for someone already retired who wants the largest guaranteed income they can get now. It is not the right fit if you want to keep control of the principal or pass a large balance to heirs, since you are trading the lump sum for the income stream.
A deferred income annuity sets up income that begins on a future date you choose, which is best for someone who wants to guarantee a paycheck for later years, such as age 80 and beyond, while they are still working or early in retirement. A version of this held inside a qualified retirement account, sometimes called a longevity annuity, can let you defer required withdrawals on the portion you place in it up to a later age, within IRS limits. It is best for someone who does not need that slice of their savings yet and wants to push the required distributions out. It is not the right fit if you need that money sooner or want full liquidity.
Indexed annuities are the most misunderstood type, mostly because of how the earnings are calculated, so it is worth slowing down on the mechanics. Your money is not invested in the market directly. Instead, the insurer credits interest based on the movement of a market index, with a floor that protects you from loss and a limit on how much of the gain you keep.
Three dials control that limit. A cap is a ceiling on the interest you can earn in a period, so if the cap is a certain percentage and the index rises more than that, your credited interest stops at the cap. A participation rate gives you a percentage of the index gain rather than all of it. For a plain example, if the participation rate is 80% and the index rises 10% in the period, you are credited 8%. A spread subtracts a set percentage from the index gain before crediting, so a 10% index gain with a 2% spread credits you 8%. In a year the index falls, the floor means you are credited zero rather than taking a loss, so you do not go backward.
These dials are how the insurer can offer downside protection, and they are exactly the fine print that varies from one product to the next. Reading them correctly is most of the work in choosing a good indexed annuity, and comparing them across carriers is where I add real value rather than letting a single illustration make the case for you.
Annuities carry costs, and they come in two flavors worth telling apart. Some costs are built in rather than billed as a line item, which is the case with the caps, participation rates, and spreads on an indexed annuity. The insurer limits your upside instead of charging you an explicit fee. Other costs are spelled out as charges, most commonly the fees inside a variable annuity and the cost of optional riders.
The most common optional add on is a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit, sometimes called an income rider. For an annual charge, usually a fraction of a percent to around one and a half percent, it guarantees you can withdraw a set amount for life even if the underlying value runs down, and it often grows a separate benefit base during the years before you turn income on. It can be a powerful way to guarantee income while keeping some access to your money, but the charge is real and only worth paying if you will actually use the income guarantee. There are also death benefit riders and inflation adjustment riders for specific goals. I separate the built in costs from the explicit ones so you see the true price of what you are buying and only pay for features you will use.
If you already own an annuity, you are not stuck with it, and a review is often worthwhile. A provision in the tax code known as a 1035 exchange lets you move from one annuity into another without triggering taxes on the gains, as long as it is done as a direct transfer rather than a cash out. That can make sense when a newer contract offers a better rate, stronger guarantees, or features your current one lacks.
There are cautions. The old contract may still carry surrender charges if you are inside its surrender period, and a new contract starts a fresh surrender schedule of its own, so an exchange only makes sense when the improvement clearly outweighs those costs. Most new annuities also include a free look period, a window of a few weeks after purchase during which you can cancel for a full refund if you change your mind. I am glad to review an annuity you already hold and tell you honestly whether keeping it, exchanging it, or leaving it alone serves you best, with no pressure to make a change that only benefits an agent.
If you hold an annuity inside a traditional IRA or another tax deferred retirement account, it is subject to the same required minimum distribution rules as the rest of that account, meaning you must begin taking a minimum amount out each year once you reach the age the rules set. An annuity bought with after tax money outside a retirement account does not carry required minimum distributions at all.
This matters for planning, because the income an annuity pays can be coordinated with the withdrawals you are already required to take, and certain longevity style annuities held in a qualified account can let you defer the required distributions on the portion you place in them up to a later age, within IRS limits. For the many retirees across Central Florida juggling several accounts, getting this coordination right avoids both penalties for taking too little and unnecessary taxes from taking too much at once. I help you fit the annuity into the larger required distribution picture rather than treating it in isolation.
I will not recommend an annuity unless I am confident it fits your situation, and I will tell you just as plainly when one does not. That honesty is the whole point of working with an independent agent rather than a salesperson tied to a single product line.
The first conversation is just a conversation, with no pressure and nothing to sign. Call me, Bradley Stone, at 407.878.8277 for a free, no obligation conversation about whether an annuity belongs in your retirement plan, serving retirees throughout Orlando, Lake County, Orange County, and Seminole County.
| Fixed | Fixed Indexed | Immediate | Deferred Income | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Principal protected from market loss | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Growth potential | Fixed guaranteed rate | Tied to an index with a floor and a cap | Not a growth product, it pays income | Grows now, income later |
| When income can start | Later | Later | Right away | On a future date you choose |
| Best for | Safety and predictable growth | Some market upside with no downside | Maximum guaranteed income now | Locking in future income |
A fixed annuity earns a guaranteed interest rate set by the insurance company, similar to a certificate of deposit. An indexed annuity ties your earnings to the performance of a market index such as the S&P 500 with downside protection, so you can participate in market gains without losing principal in a down year. A variable annuity invests your money directly in market sub accounts and has the most upside and the most downside risk.
Fixed and indexed annuities offer principal protection guaranteed by the issuing insurance company. Florida also has a state guaranty association that backs annuity contracts up to set limits if the insurance company itself fails. The safety of an annuity depends heavily on the financial strength of the carrier you choose, which is one of the things I evaluate when I recommend a contract.
With a fixed or indexed annuity, you cannot lose principal due to market performance. You can lose money to surrender charges if you withdraw funds early, or to fees inside a variable annuity. Reading the contract carefully, choosing a carrier with strong financial ratings, and matching the surrender period to your time horizon prevents most of the common ways people lose money on annuities.
The growth inside an annuity is tax deferred while it stays in the contract. When you start taking money out, the earnings portion is taxed as ordinary income. If you bought the annuity with after tax money, your original contributions come back tax free. Annuities held inside an IRA follow the same rules as your IRA.
Annuities work best for people who want guaranteed retirement income, principal protection, tax deferred growth, or a way to convert a lump sum into a paycheck. They are usually a poor fit for people who need easy access to all their money in the short term, or who already have enough guaranteed income from Social Security and pensions to cover their basic expenses.
A surrender period is the number of years during which withdrawing more than a set amount triggers a surrender charge. It exists because the insurance company is committing to long term guarantees and needs your money to stay put long enough to deliver them. It matters because you should never put money into an annuity that you may need to pull out early. I match the surrender schedule to your time horizon so the fine print never surprises you.
An annuity is the wrong tool when you need full access to the money in the short term, when you already have plenty of guaranteed income covering your basic expenses, or when a high fee product like many variable annuities is being oversold to you. Because I am independent, I have no reason to push one on you, and I will tell you plainly when an annuity does not belong in your plan.
A multi year guaranteed annuity, or MYGA, locks in a set interest rate for a chosen term of several years, similar to a certificate of deposit. The main differences are that a MYGA often pays a higher rate, its growth is tax deferred until you withdraw rather than taxed each year, and it is backed by the issuing insurer and Florida's guaranty association rather than by federal deposit insurance. It suits a conservative saver who does not need the money during the term.
An income rider, often called a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit, guarantees you can withdraw a set amount for life even if the underlying account value runs down, usually for an annual charge of a fraction of a percent up to around one and a half percent. It is worth the cost only if you will actually use the lifetime income guarantee. If you mainly want growth or full access to your money, you may be paying for a feature you will not use, and I help you decide.
Not from market drops. A fixed indexed annuity credits interest based on a market index but includes a floor, so in a year the index falls you are credited zero rather than taking a loss. Your upside is limited by a cap, a participation rate, or a spread, which is the tradeoff for that protection. You can still lose money to surrender charges if you withdraw early, so matching the surrender period to your time horizon matters.
Often yes, through a provision called a 1035 exchange, which lets you move from one annuity into another as a direct transfer without triggering taxes on the gains. It can make sense when a newer contract offers a better rate or stronger guarantees. Watch for surrender charges on the old contract and a fresh surrender schedule on the new one. I review what you already own and tell you honestly whether an exchange actually helps you.
An annuity held inside a traditional IRA or similar retirement account follows the same required minimum distribution rules as the rest of that account, so you must begin taking a minimum amount each year at the set age. An annuity bought with after tax money outside a retirement account has no required minimum distributions. I help you coordinate annuity income with the withdrawals you are already required to take so you avoid penalties and unnecessary taxes.
Tell Stone Financial Partners what you need and we will get back to you within 24 hours.
Prefer to talk? Call (407) 878-8277